Skip to main content

HR 544 And Health Premium Rates (Update) Liberty Act

In my previous blog regarding the "Liberty Act" HR 544 seeks to increase the mandated ratio of premium pricing from 3:1 to 5:1 to help reduce monthly health insurance premium costs to younger people.  Currently the PPACA requires that the maximum rate differential between the oldest subscriber and youngest cannot be more than 3 times the youngest subscriber's rate.

To understand what is at issue for younger California residents (and other states as well), we need to first look at rate differential under the current underwriting (can be denied if too risky) system which enrolls only generally healthy individuals.

For my area zip code 95020:

Clear Protection Plus 3300 PPO (most popular plan in CA) at standard monthly rate:

Age 19 - $86.00
Age 63 - $347.06
Age 19 Adjusted to PPACA Ratio - $115.67 (immediate 35% Rate Increase)

1/3 of the age 63 rate would be $115.67.  Under the current system (not a guaranteed-issue take all comers system), the 19-year-old would experience an immediate 35% rate increase on 1/1/2014 to meet the mandatory 3:1 ratio.  The carrier is certainly not going to lower the age 63 rate.  

SmartSense Plus 6000 PPO with Standard Rx at standard monthly rate:

Age 19 - $109.00
Age 63 - $436.00
Age 19 Adjusted to PPACA - $145.33 (immediate 33% Rate Increase)

1/3 of the age 63 rate would be $145.33.  Under the current system (not a guaranteed-issue take all comers system), the 19-year-old would experience an immediate 33% rate increase on 1/1/2014 to meet the mandatory 3:1 ratio.  

As you can see by the examples above, the immediate impact IF the current underwriting system were kept in place and high risks could be denied would result in an IMMEDIATE rate increase for a healthy 19-year-old of approximately 34% across the board.  

Further assuming that rates will be adjusted upward of these current lower-risk underwritten rates to accommodate community rated guaranteed-issue coverage and cover all required essential health benefits and precious metal tier requirements, the rate for the 19-year-old could be stratospheric.  It will certainly be more than the current 34% average increase as the medical underwriting system will disappear and anyone, regardless of health can buy coverage at the same premium rate as someone at the same age in their rating area (community rating).

HR 544 would increase the ratio from 3:1 to 5:1 which would then allow some relief for those at younger ages with the ability of the insurer to price at 1/5 the price of the 63-year-old and not 1/3 the price.

Young people need to be concerned about this.  I have heard rumors that one organization, an association for retired people, is fighting against this bill.  Young people need to be concerned or their health insurance rates (you have to buy it by law staring next January or face a penalty or tax or whatever they are calling it).  



  1. Thanks for the updates, Dave! Your post about premium rates is really informative. It gives awareness to everyone regarding the rates they pay. I’m so glad that I dropped by. I believe everyone should see this. Thanks!

    Fe Penley

  2. Very nice post here and thanks for it .I always like and such a super contents of these post.Excellent and very cool idea and great content of different kinds of the valuable information's.
    Cheapest Health Insurance Dubai


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Anthem Blue Cross (CA) Adding SilverSneakers® Fitness Program

Anthem Blue Cross (CA) announced this morning that they will be adding the SilverSneakers Fitness Program to California Medicare Supplement Plans A, F, and N.  The added benefit will begin on January 1st, 2017. 

Once approved for release into the market, more states have been added to the list as existing and new members in our marketed plans will enjoy the value-added benefits of the SilverSneakers Fitness program at no additional cost! Effective January 1, 2017, California members in our marketed plans will enjoy SilverSneakers, too.  The program offers members their choice of paths to better health. For those who enjoy a traditional workout setting, SilverSneakers offers access to more than 13,000 fitness locations across the country, including use of classes and guidance from a Program AdvisorTM. In addition, for those who can’t get to a fitness center, SilverSneakers Steps® kits focus on at-home or on-the-go general fitness, walking, strength training or yoga. And if that is not …

Anthem Blue Cross Announces Innovative F Medicare Supplement Plan for CA

Anthem Blue Cross (CA) has announced that they are releasing a new Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plan for California residents.  The plan will be available beginning January 1st, 2018.

'Innovative F' will offer benefits not covered by a Medicare Supplement base plan.  These will include a hearing benefit (exam, fitting and allowance) and a vision benefit (exam, lens co-pay and allowances for frames and contact lenses).

Anthem states that the Innovative F will have a very competitive premium rate.  Innovative F will include the Silver Sneakers fitness program and will be eligible for the Plan F 'new to Medicare' $20 per month first year discount.


What Multi State Plan (MSP) Really Means (Covered CA)

Lots of confusion on this term and many people think it involves coverage across state lines.  It does not.

This explanation from Anthem Blue Cross is the best one I have seen:

The U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM) Multi-State Plan Program (MSPP) was recently established under the Affordable Care Act. It directs the OPM to contract with health insurance carriers to offer at least two plans (one at the silver level and one at the gold level) in each local exchange. The MSPP is intended to promote competition in the Marketplace and help ensure consumers have more high-quality, affordable health insurance options. All MSPP plans will include “a Multi-State Plan” at the end of their name when listed on the exchange - this designates it as an OPM-sponsored plans.  It does NOT mean that consumers selecting the plan will have health plan coverage in multiple states.Select silver and gold level Individual plans that our company currently offers have been designated as OPM-sponsored MSPP…